Sunday, September 27, 2009

BCMSN Hotspot: Spanning Tree

Scenario:
CiscoSims is an Internet game provider. The game service network had recently added an additional switch block with multiple VLANs configured. Unfortunately, system administrators neglected to document the spanning tree topology during configuration. For baseline purpose, you will be required to identify the spanning-tree topology for the switch block.




Using the output of "show spanning-tree" command on switch SW-C and the provided physical topology, answer the following questions:

Questions & Answers:

Question 1:
Which spanning Tree Protocol has been implemented on SW-B?

A. STP/IEEE 802.1D
B. MSTP/IEEE 802.1s
C. PVST+
D. PVRST
E. None of the above

Explanation:
802.1D has not been implemented since this is CST (Common Spanning Tree) which only allows one instance to be run at a time per Network. In this scenario there are multiple instances. It must be PVST+ since each instance only contains one VLAN.
..................................................................................................................................................
Question 2:
Which bridge ID belongs to SW-B?

A. 24623.000f.34f5.0138
B. 32768.000d.bd03.0380
C. 32768.000d.65db.0l02
D. 32769.000d.65db.0l02
E. 32874.000d.db03.0380
F. 32815.000d.db03.0380

Explanation:
Root ports are ports that point to the Root Bridge. In the exhibit, under VLAN 47 we see that fa0/2 is a root port for VLAN 47. Since we assume that all paths have equal cost we can gather that the root ports destination is the root bridge itself. In this case the Root Bridge for VLAN 47 is SW-B and according the exhibit the MAC address is 24623 000f 34f5 0138
.....................................................................................................................................................
Question 3:
Which port role has interface Fa0/2 of SW-A adopted for VLAN 47?

A. Root port
B. Nondesigned port
C. Designated port
D. Backup port
E. Alternate port

Explanation:
Refer to Explanation for previous question. So far we know that SW-B is the Root Bridge for VLAN 47. We also see that SW-C is using fa0/2 as its root port. Therefore SW-A will use fa0/1 for its Root port and fa0/2 will be designated since fa0/1 on SW-C is blocking. Note: If one segment of SPT is in blocking statusthe distantend port is not. Otherwise BPDUs could not be transmitted and would negate the redundancy.
.................................................................................................................................................
Question 4:
Which port state is interface Fa0/2 of SW-B in for VLANs 1 and 106?

A. Listening
B. Learning
C. Disabled
D. Blocking
E. Forwarding
F. Discarding

Explanation:
For VLAN 1 and 106 we can conclude that the Root Bridge is SW-A. With this in mind SW-B will use fa0/1 for its root port and block the other since the Cost will be lower. In this case it will block fa0/2 for both VLANs (and most likely fa0/3 also since SW-D is using fa0/1 as its root port).
...............................................................................................................................................
Question 5:
Which bridge ID belongs to SW-A?

A. 24623.000f.34fS.0138
B. 32768.000d.bd03.0380
c. 32768.000d.65db.0102
D. 32769.000d.65db.0102
E. 32874 .000d .db03.0380
F. 32815.000d.db03.0380

Explanation:
We see that in VLAN 1 and VLAN 106 that fa0/1 is the root port on SW-C. As previously discussed we know that root ports point to the root bridge and assuming equal cost from switch to root and the fact that no other port is root for either VLAN that SW-A is the Root Bridge and we can gleen the information for the exhibit which list the Bridge's VLAN.
.................................................................................

12 comments:

  1. About Q4,
    Shouldn't it be Discarding since RSTP protocol is used ? There are only 3 states for RSTP: Discarding, Learning, and Forwarding.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good question!
    In the 'show span' command, you can see that the fa0/2 of SW-C is changed to STP, because it is connected to a switch running STP. So the state of Fa0/2 of SW-B is not discarding, but blocking.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh, that's right ! Thanks, ciscosims.

    ReplyDelete
  4. About Q4 and Q1:
    If SW-C fa 0/2 is STP then SW-B should be running 802.1D for Q1

    ReplyDelete
  5. No, STP also means PVST+
    It cant be 802.1d coz there are multiple instances.

    ReplyDelete
  6. About Q4 and Q1

    Type P2P Peer(STP)represents that the neighboor is running PVST because of that on Q1 the answer is "D"

    ReplyDelete
  7. If you see P2p Peer(STP), the port is a point-to-point type but the neighboring device is running
    traditional 802.1D STP.
    So the answer for Q1 is "A"

    see reference on Cisco Press BCMSN
    Page 272

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hello,
    I found that Study Guides are often ambiguous and vague about "show" questions.The best way to sovle "show" question is to look for this command or output on cisco.com site. 95% of such questions are directly from cisco online docs.
    In this case, go cisco.com -> search "P2p peer (STP)" -> bingo!:

    !--- Type P2p peer (STP) represent that the neighbor switch runs PVST

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi finaly what are the answers. As someone wrote in question 1 I have read in BCMSN study quide "If you see P2p Peer(STP), the port is a point-to-point type but the neighboring device is running
    traditional 802.1D STP."

    in question 5:
    for vlan 101 has root priority 24682 so I think there are no equal bridge ID(could be find at Switch#sh spann bridge)


    And finaly: I heard there are some new sims and questions in BCMSN. Do you know something about it?

    ReplyDelete
  10. HI it is avalid Hotsport Question for BCMSN... let me know even know me latest for the same

    ReplyDelete
  11. fa0/1 is root ports for VLAN 1,106
    sw-a - probably root, then see bridge id in listening commands:
    Root ID priority for VLAN 1: 32769
    ROOT ID priority for VLAN 106: 24682

    why answer D. 32769.000d.65db.0102 ???

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi my sweet Buddy’s,
    Toady I completed my CCNP Composite exam & scored 991/1000.

    Questions are from Test-inside dumps TI 5.25, it’s a valid one.

    Got 4 SIMS:
    AAA DOT1X Radius
    IPV6 Virtual Link
    EIGRP ISIS redistribution
    EIGRP Stub

    3 SPOT
    HSRP
    EIGRP Simlet
    Spanning tree

    No Drag & Drop……………………
    Best of Luck guys…………. Only 1 day is left
    Thanks to ciscosims……… It’s a nice site to refer………

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.